And here’s to you, Mrs. Robinson
2 December, 2015
And here’s to you, Mrs. Robinson,
Jesus loves you more than you will know.
God bless you, please Mrs. Robinson.
Heaven holds a place for those who pray,
Hey, hey, hey
Hey, hey, hey
So our ex-President Mrs Mary Robinson is to open the State’s first presidential archive and research centre in 2017. Good for her.
In a touching piece in the Irish Times, Robinson-biographer and acolyte Lorna Siggins tells us that “A quarter of a century after her promise to keep a symbolic candle in the window of Áras an Uachtaráin, former president Mary Robinson has outlined plans to brighten her north Mayo birthplace with the State’s first presidential archive and research centre. The €8.35 million centre in her former family home – the 19th-century Victoria House, overlooking the river Moy in Ballina – will open in the second quarter of 2017, Mrs Robinson said in Ballina at the weekend.”
€8.35 million! Wow, that’s very generous of her, isn’t it? Why, I’m almost ready to forgive her for quitting her pathetic little job as President of Ireland in 1997 two months early so she could nail down a real job with the United Nations as their High Commissioner for Human Rights.
Oh but wait a minute, Mary isn’t paying for the house – you and I are footing most of the bill it seems. Here’s what Lorna tells us:
- €1.5 million has been provided by Mayo County Council to buy the house and to provide an adjoining site for construction of an annexe, along with architectural and design services;
- The State has committed just over €2 million through the Department of the Taoiseach;
- Mrs Robinson has donated her archive, valued at €2.5 million, to the State, under section 1003 of the Taxes Consolidation Act 1997, which provides that people who donate heritage items can credit the value against certain tax liabilities.
So this vanity project for Mrs Robinson will cost the Irish citizens up to €5.5 million, depending on what is the net effect on the State coffers of the tax foregone as a result of the big fat tax credit she will get. She may not have thought enough of us to serve her full term as President, but obviously our money is as good as anybody else’s.
It seems that the archive “will house files relating to Mrs Robinson’s legal work, her presidential engagements from December 1990 to September 1997 and her term as UN high commissioner for human rights from 1997 to 2002.”
I am impressed with the prescience she showed in keeping safe all those boxes of files spanning some five decades. She must have been confident from an early date that history was being created.
However, in my self-appointed role as intrepid defender of the hard-pressed Irish taxpayer, I have to ask two questions: (a) How come the archive is worth €2.5 million and who decided this? And (b) how come the papers in the archive are Mrs Robinson’s to donate in the first place?
The latter question is interesting. Mrs Robinson, both as President of Ireland and as UN High Commissioner for Human Rights was effectively employed by and paid for by Ireland and the United Nations respectively. Under most legal systems and contractual arrangements with which I am familiar, any materials produced in the course of the execution of the paid-for role belong to the employer organisation, not the individual involved.
Why are the files relating to her presidential engagements from December 1990 to September 1997 not already the property of the State? Why are we effectively paying for them twice – the first time through her salary when she was President and was generating the relevant papers, and now in giving her an 80% tax credit for handing them over to us? Maybe we need to take a look at the terms of our Presidential “employment contract”.
If Mrs Robinson is anything, she is ethical and law-abiding. So I’m sure everything is above board. But somebody has to ask the right questions. If you are waiting for the Irish Times to ask any challenging questions of her, don’t hold your breath.
PS…. I note that for our money we also will get a research centre that will have “a particular emphasis on the ‘critical area of women’s leadership’, unleashing ‘energy for change’ through women’s empowerment”. I can’t wait.
We’d like to know a little bit about you for our files
We’d like to help you learn to help yourself.
Look around you all you see are sympathetic eyes,
Stroll around the grounds until you feel at home…..