No votes for public sector employees?!
13 November, 2011
You may think that I am on occasion anti-public sector in my pronouncements (actually I’m not; I just think that Irish public sector management is lazy and inefficient and provides poor leadership). Anyway, compared to the guy quoted below, I am a pussycat.
Dr J C Lester argues that only (net) taxpayers should be allowed to vote, thus ruling out state sector employees!
Why should people who are not taxpayers be allowed to vote money away from those who are? If we must have state services, it should at least be for those who pay for them to vote for which services they want and how much they wish to pay. To allow those providing, or living off, the services to vote is like allowing a shopkeeper to vote on what you must buy from him, or a beggar to vote on what you must give him….
… Consider state distribution of tax-money. We can see that this must create two social categories: those who are net taxpayers and those who are net tax recipients. Only the net taxpayers can be said to provide the state with tax-funds. The net tax recipients are paid out of taxation, plus any payments in newly created state-currency (which effectively taxes those who hold money). So to the extent that people are in the pay of the state they cannot be genuine taxpayers. A proof of this is that if their jobs were abolished the state would have more money to spend elsewhere, unlike those jobs in the genuinely taxpaying sector.
The writer, Jan Lester, is a leading member of the Libertarian Alliance. The public sector seems to be a prevalent theme of writing on the LA website. Its home page currently has a lead article by D.J. Webb called “Living off our Taxes”, of which the introduction gives a flavour:
There is nothing more frustrating than having to pay tax and national insurance so that public-sectors workers can earn more than you. People in the private sector face greater job insecurity and have less lavishly funded pension arrangements, where such arrangements even exist, and yet they are the golden goose that has to be repeated slaughtered in order that state workers can have secure and higher-paid jobs with astonishingly generous pension provision.
In case you were wondering, Webb was writing about the United Kingdom, not Ireland. But, let’s be honest, he could have been writing about Ireland.